There’s a particular brand of escapism that fantasy promises, a heady cocktail of ornate costumes, mythical creatures, and worlds unburdened by the banality of our own. "Carnival Row," Amazon’s foray into this well-trodden genre, seemed poised to deliver. It had the budget, the elaborate steampunk aesthetic, and a cast led by the enigmatic Cara Delevingne. Yet, somewhere between the cobblestones and faerie wings, the illusion faltered.
Delevingne, with her preternatural brows and air of world-weariness, seemed a natural fit for the role of Vignette Stonemoss, a faerie refugee seeking sanctuary in a human world growing increasingly hostile. And indeed, there are moments when she inhabits the character's wounded vulnerability with a raw intensity. A flicker of pain in her eyes, the way she carries herself with a quiet defiance - these moments hint at the actress Delevingne could be.
But these moments are too often fleeting, overshadowed by the show's relentless desire to dazzle rather than delve. The world-building, while ambitious, feels curiously hollow. The societal tensions between humans and the mythical “creatures” feel like well-worn tropes, lacking the nuance and complexity that would elevate them beyond mere allegory. It’s all a bit like a lavishly produced stage play where the actors haven’t quite learned their lines.
And then there’s the matter of the plot. It lurches forward in fits and starts, propelled more by contrivance than genuine narrative momentum. One minute we’re embroiled in a murder mystery, the next we’re subjected to clunky exposition dumps about the history of this fantastical world. The result is a show that feels both overstuffed and strangely empty, like a Christmas stocking filled with packing peanuts.
This isn’t to say that "Carnival Row" is entirely without merit. The production design is undeniably impressive, creating a visually arresting world that blends Victorian grime with fantastical elements. And there are supporting performances, like that of Indira Varma as the steely faerie madam, that crackle with a vitality missing from the show’s leads.
But ultimately, "Carnival Row" feels like a missed opportunity. It mistakes spectacle for substance, sacrificing character development and narrative coherence for elaborate set pieces and CGI-laden action sequences. It’s a shame, because there are glimmers of something genuinely interesting here, buried beneath the weight of the show’s own ambition.
Perhaps it’s unfair to lay the blame for the show’s shortcomings solely at Delevingne’s feet. She is, after all, just one piece in a much larger puzzle. But as the show’s ostensible lead, she is also the one most burdened by its failings. And in the end, "Carnival Row" serves as a reminder that even the most beautiful plumage can’t disguise a lack of substance.
I remember attending a runway show years ago, a young designer’s debut collection. The clothes were exquisite, a riot of color and texture, but they lacked a certain…soul. It was as if the designer was so preoccupied with creating a spectacle that they forgot to tell a story. "Carnival Row" evokes that same feeling – a sense of wasted potential, of style over substance. And like that fleeting fashion moment, it’s a show that ultimately leaves you feeling cold, despite all its surface glitter.
Shop the must-have Taylor Swift outfits- https://www.cusuti.com/category/taylor-swift
Comments