Pop music, with its cyclical nature, loves a good coronation. We crave it, really. The anointing of the next reigning queen, the passing of the torch, the sparkly scepter (microphone?) handed down. Recently, a narrative has emerged, one that positions Olivia Rodrigo and now, Sabrina Carpenter, as heirs to Taylor Swift’s throne. It’s a tempting storyline, sure. All three are gifted songwriters, adept at channeling heartbreak into chart-topping confessions. But the truth, as is often the case, is far more nuanced.
Carpenter’s latest album, "Emails I Can't Send," has drawn inevitable comparisons to Swift’s work, particularly the confessional, often scathing lyrics. And yes, the parallels are there. The album simmers with the aftermath of a high-profile, very public, very messy love triangle (cue the collective eyebrow raise of anyone with an internet connection). But to reduce Carpenter to simply “Swift 2.0” feels, at best, lazy and at worst, dismissive of her own distinct artistry.
Swift, for all her songwriting prowess, emerged at a specific cultural moment. The dawn of social media was just beginning to intertwine with celebrity, creating a perfect storm for her brand of intimate, diaristic pop. She was the girl next door, if the girl next door wrote catchy, devastating songs about the football captain who broke her heart.
Carpenter, however, navigates a vastly different landscape. The internet is no longer a nascent force but a roaring, often unforgiving beast. Her every move, every lyric, every Instagram caption is dissected and debated in real-time. This hyper-visibility lends a certain self-awareness to her music, a knowing wink that acknowledges the absurdity of it all.
I remember once, years ago, sitting in a dingy backstage area with a young pop star. She was on the verge of massive fame, her face plastered on billboards across the city. We were talking about the pressure, the scrutiny, the constant feeling of being watched. “It’s like living in a fishbowl,” she said, her voice barely a whisper. “Except the fishbowl is on fire.”
That image, the burning fishbowl, has always stuck with me. It perfectly encapsulates the precariousness of fame in the digital age, a reality Carpenter knows all too well. Her music doesn't shy away from this; it leans into it. There's a defiance in her lyrics, a refusal to be defined solely by the narratives others project onto her.
And this is where the comparison to Swift, while understandable, ultimately falters. Swift, at least in her early career, often played the role of the sympathetic victim, the heartbroken girl seeking solace in her songwriting. Carpenter, on the other hand, refuses to be cast as a victim. She owns her narrative, even the messy, complicated parts, with a boldness that feels refreshingly modern.
This isn't to say that Carpenter's music lacks emotional depth. On the contrary, "Emails I Can't Send" is brimming with vulnerability and raw honesty. But there's a strength, a resilience, that sets it apart. She's not asking for our pity; she's demanding our attention. And she's doing it on her own terms.
The truth is, pop music doesn't need another Taylor Swift. It needs artists like Sabrina Carpenter, artists who are willing to push boundaries, to challenge expectations, and to carve out their own unique space in the ever-evolving landscape of popular culture. The throne, as they say, is vacant. And Carpenter isn't interested in inheriting it; she's building her own damn castle.
Shop the must-have Taylor Swift outfits- https://www.cusuti.com/category/taylor-swift
Comments